Goodfellas Pizzeria - OTR Menu
Welcome to Goodfellas Pizzeria - OTR, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Cincinnati. This pizza restaurant not only serves mouth-watering pizzas but also boasts an impressive whiskey collection, making it a perfect stop for food lovers and cocktail enthusiasts alike.
The standout feature of their menu is, without a doubt, the amazing pizza. Reviewers rave about the chewy and crunchy crust, which is consistently described as perfection. You’ll find generous slices topped with fresh ingredients that leave patrons longing for more. The garlic breadsticks are also a must-try, often paired with nacho cheese for a delightful twist.
The atmosphere is relaxed and family-friendly, with upstairs seating until 9 p.m., making it suitable for all ages. Coupled with the warm, welcoming staff, Goodfellas Pizzeria - OTR ensures a memorable dining experience that keeps guests coming back for more.
Bottles & Cans
-
Coors Banquet
US$3.71
-
Blue Moon N/A
US$5.57
-
Suncruiser
US$6.49
Desserts
-
Cannoli
A housemade Italian pastry filled with sweet ricotta and chocolate chips
US$4.00
-
Chocolate Chip Cookie
An extra large staple cookie with extra chocolate
US$4.00
-
Black and White Cookie
Seinfeld's favorite... a New York staple
US$4.00
-
Cheesecake
Hands down the best you've ever had!
US$4.00
Vodka
-
Deep Eddy
US$6.00
Tequila
-
Casamigos Jalapeno
US$17.00
-
Jose Cuervo Devil's Reserve
US$5.00
-
Novo Fogo Cachaca
US$9.00
-
Espolon Repo
US$9.00
-
Corazon Reposado - Aged in Sazerac Rye "Te-Kill-Ya"
US$15.00
-
Hornitos Cucumber & Habanero
US$9.00
Calzones
-
Calzone
This half moon turnover is stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella, and your choice of toppings. Prepare to share!
US$11.00
Subs
-
Al Pacino
An extra large meatball sub sandwich with our signature marinara sauce, on a toasted Tribeca bread baguette, and stuffed with the best meatballs you'll ever taste!
US$11.00
Glass
-
Wycliff Champagne
US$6.00
Gin
-
Bulrush Gin
US$12.00
-
Monk's Road Gin
US$9.00
-
Boone County Gin
US$5.00
-
Five Stores Barrel Aged Gin
US$15.00
-
Guild Chamomile Gin
US$12.00
-
Four Peel Barrel Aged Gin
US$12.00
-
Cruzan Rum Island Reserve 13 yr.
US$10.00
Liqueurs
-
Giffard Lichi-Li
US$10.00
-
Nux Alpina
US$12.00
-
Rothmann Orchard Pear
US$8.00
-
See The Elephant Amaro
US$14.00
-
Shochu Yokaichi Mugi
US$8.00
-
Thatchers Cucumber
US$6.00
-
Velvet Falernum
US$5.00
-
Yellow Chartreuse 1oz
US$14.00
-
Green Chartreuse 1oz
US$14.00
-
Chinola Passionfruit
US$7.00
-
Fratello
US$10.00
Sides
-
Cheese Bread
Our original hand tossed dough brushed with garlic butter and covered with a pile of mozzarella. Finished with oregano and perfect for sharing.
US$13.00
-
Extra Sauce
Marinara, Ranch, Garlic Butter, Nacho Cheese, Buffalo Ranch
US$1.00
-
Pesto Bread
A New York Tribeca bread baguette, spread with a generous amount of housemade pesto, topped with mozzarella and baked till golden brown.
US$10.00
-
Breadstick
A single breadstick that is literally the size of your arm. Covered in garlic butter, parmesan, and dusted with oregano. Served with your choice of sauce
US$4.00
-
Buff Chicken Cheese Bread
Need we say more? This snack is a tastebud pleaser! Served with housemade ranch
US$16.00
-
Dough Ball
Our hand made dough prepared so that you can take one home and make your own pizza.
US$3.00
-
Sun Dried Tomato Bread
A New York Tribeca bread baguette brushed with garlic infused olive oil, topped with imported Italian sun dried tomatoes, cheese, and finished with fresh basil.
US$10.00
-
Meatballs
Our world class meatballs made of pork and beef are smothered in our house made marinara and topped with ricotta and basil... Mangia! *soy,milk,gluten,egg
US$11.00
Rum
-
Hard Truth Toasted Coconut Rum
US$7.00
-
Planteray Cut and Dry
US$13.00
Pies
-
12" Half & Half Pie
Can't come to an agreement with the family... Split it down the middle with a 12" half pie all to yourself.
US$14.00
-
22" Half & Half Pie
Can't come to an agreement with the family... Split it down the middle with a 22" half pie all to yourself.
US$25.00
-
12" Pie
Build your own 12" pizza like a Boss! Start with a plain cheese and make it like Sinatra... "Your Way"
US$14.00
-
22" Pie
Build your own 22" pizza like a Boss! Start with a plain cheese and make it like Sinatra... "Your Way"
US$25.00
-
16" Half & Half Pie
Can't come to an agreement with the family... Split it down the middle with a 16" half pie all to yourself.
US$19.00
-
16" Pie
Build your own 16" pizza like a Boss! Start with a plain cheese and make it like Sinatra... "Your Way"
US$19.00
-
GF HABANERO BOTTLE
US$2.00
Classic
-
Greenpoint
US$15.00
Salads
-
Caprese Salad
A simple salad made of fresh Fior di Latte mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, then drizzled with olive oil and seasoned
US$4.50
-
Spring Mix Salad
A small side salad with fresh spring mix, red onions, tomatoes, and sliced button mushrooms.
US$4.50
-
Pasta Salad
A tri-colored rotini pasta salad tossed with diced roma tomatoes, banana peppers, black olives, red onion, and broccoli. Finished with housemade Italian dressing.
US$4.50
Specialty Pies
-
Wiseguy
Straight from the garden with green peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives, and tomatoes
US$18.00
-
Taste of Naples
Travel back to the "old country" with this margherita pie made with our signature marinara sauce, basil and fresh mozzarella
US$18.00
-
The Bootlegger
Nucky Thompson approved with spinach, mushroom, sundried tomatoes, and pesto (try it with chicken)
US$18.00
-
Goodfella
A meaty pie suitable for any gangster with pepperoni, Italian rope sausage, ground beef, and bacon.
US$19.00
-
Paulie's Favorite
Paulie's passion for cooking sausage inspired this pie with spicy sliced Italian sausage, garlic sausage crumble, green peppers, onions, a roasted garlic
US$19.00
-
The Don
The choice for any head of the family with pepperoni, Italian rope sausage, ground beef, bacon, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, and black olives
US$29.00
-
Fuhgetaboutit
Every available topping... Fuhgetaboutit!
US$48.00
-
The Vinny
a friend of the family's traditional white pie made with olive oil, ricotta, roasted garlic, and mozzarella (try it with sausage)
US$17.00
-
Tommy "Two Times"
Two times the amount of pepperoni!
US$17.00
-
The Boss
Calling the shots with chicken, tomatoes, onions, bacon, and drizzled ranch
US$40.00
-
Nonna's Pie
Just how Nonna used to make pasta, except as a pizza. Meatballs, red onion, ricotta, garlic, and basil. Mangia!
US$40.00
-
National Pizza Week Pie
12" BBQ Chicken (call-in and in-house ONLY)
US$12.00
Beverages
-
Bottled Water
Goodfellas very own bottled spring water
US$1.75
-
Red Bull
US$3.75
-
Soda
Coca-cola products in a reusable Goodfellas stadium cup
US$3.25
Shots
-
St. Patty's Boilermaker Mass
US$13.00
-
Irish Tea
US$6.00
-
Gullymaker
US$11.00
-
Jello Shot
US$3.00
Bottle
-
Wycliff Bottle
US$20.00
Mocktail
-
Dirty Little Secret
US$9.00
-
Nice Guys Finish Last
US$9.00
-
Calmer Seas
US$8.00
-
Nawgroni
US$9.00
-
Zeroyale
US$8.00
-
Lil Miss Strawberry
US$8.00
-
San Pellegrino Pompelmo
US$6.00
-
San Pellegrino Aranciata Rossa
US$6.00
-
Seedlip Spice 94
US$9.00
-
Seedlip Grove 42
US$9.00
Retail Gear Shop
-
Legalize Marinara, Green
US$18.54
Goodfellas Depot
-
Roll of Delivery Seals - Quality Ingredients Inside This Box
US$5.00
-
Roll of Delivery Seals - Taste The Difference
US$5.00
World Whiskey - Canada
-
Canadian Club
US$5.00
Flight
-
Luck of the Irish Flight
US$20.00
-
Pinhook Derby Day Flight
US$30.00
-
Woodford Bourbon Heritage Flight
US$25.00
-
Buffalo Trace Bourbon Heritage Flight
US$25.00
-
Michters BHM Flight
US$25.00
-
The Bourbon Queen
US$14.00
-
Russell's BHM Flight
US$30.00
Events
-
Marketing - Goodfellas Tent (10x10)
US$700.00
-
Marketing - Checkered Tablecloth
US$20.00
-
Marketing - Step & Repeat Goodfellas Banner
US$149.00
-
Marketing - Step & Repeat Banner Wiseguy
US$149.00
-
Marketing - Prize Wheel
US$100.00
-
Marketing - Table (6ft)
US$75.00
-
Marketing - Display Basket
US$20.00
-
Marketing - Table Spanks
US$20.00
-
Marketing - Desperados Tent (10x10)
US$700.00
-
Marketing - Display Books (Set of 3)
US$30.00
Alcohol Spend
-
Crude "Big Bear" Coffee & Cocoa Bitters
US$12.00
Equipment, Signage & Marketing Materials
-
(Bundle 100) - Food Special Door Hangers
US$20.00
Bourbon
-
1792 Full Proof Wiseguy "Mr. Pink"
US$14.00
-
1792 Full Proof Wiseguy "Mr. Pink" 1oz
US$8.00
-
Buffalo Trace "Assassin" Wiseguy
US$14.00
-
George Dickel Classic Recipe
US$8.00
-
Green River 1885
US$6.00
-
Green River Full Proof 1oz
US$13.00
-
Monk's Road Small Batch
US$15.00
-
Penelope Four Grain
US$14.00
-
Pinhook Orange "Bourbon Resolve"
US$14.00
-
Pinhook Purple "Bourbon Resolve"
US$18.00
-
Pinhook Green Rye
US$14.00
-
Rattle & Snap Tennessee Whiskey
US$13.00
-
Templeton Straight Rye
US$10.00
-
Angel's Envy Triple Oak
US$22.00
-
Angel's Envy Triple Oak 1oz
US$12.00
-
High West Midwinter Night's Dram Act 11 Scene 3
US$50.00
-
High West Midwinter Night's Dram Act 11 Scene 3 1oz
US$30.00
-
High West Cask Collection Petit Sirah
US$25.00
-
High West Cask Collection Petit Sirah 1oz
US$15.00
-
High West Cask Strength
US$25.00
-
High West Cask Strength 1oz
US$15.00
-
Little Book: The Infinite
US$65.00
-
Little Book: The Infinite 1oz
US$35.00
-
Whistlepig Home-Field Hog 3 (OHLQ)
US$20.00
-
Whistlepig Home-Field Hog 3 (OHLQ) 1oz
US$12.00
-
St. Elmo Vanilla Vodka
US$5.00
-
Karrikin Shifu
US$5.00
-
Whistlepig Snout to Tail Toasted Barrel 10yr
US$24.00
-
Whistlepig Snout to Tail Toasted Barrel 10yr 1oz
US$16.00
-
True Story Finished Bourbon
US$19.00
-
Whistlepig Campstock 1oz
US$16.00
-
Old Forester "Crime Scene" Single Barrel Barrel Proof
US$30.00
-
Old Forester "Crime Scene" Single Barrel Barrel Proof 1oz
US$18.00
-
Stagg Jr Wiseguy "Missing in Action"
US$60.00
-
Stagg Jr Wiseguy "Missing in Action" 1oz
US$36.00
-
Uncle Nearest Green
US$11.00
-
Uncle Nearest Single Barrel
US$32.00
-
Uncle Nearest Single Barrel 1oz
US$19.00
-
Mary Dowling Winter Wheat Bourbon
US$19.00
-
Penelope Wheated Bourbon
US$15.00
-
George Remus Baby Ruth Reserve
US$70.00
-
George Remus Baby Ruth Reserve 1oz
US$40.00
-
Jack Daniel's Coy Hill Barrelhouse Bourbon 1oz
US$18.00
-
Four Roses OBSF
US$16.00
-
Northern Liberties BiB Small Batch Whiskey
US$23.00
-
Northern Liberties BiB Small Batch Whiskey 1oz
US$13.00
-
Old Grand Dad High Rye 7YR
US$12.00
-
Penelope Tokaji Cask Finish Rye
US$30.00
-
Penelope Tokaji Cask Finish Rye 1oz
US$18.00
-
1792 Full Proof "Executive Decision"
US$14.00
-
1792 Full Proof "Executive Decision" 1oz
US$8.00
-
Heaven's Door Revelation
US$18.00
-
Penelope Cigar Blend 01
US$25.00
-
Penelope Cigar Blend 01 1oz
US$15.00
-
Jim Beam Pineapple
US$6.00
-
Penelope Architect Creme Brulee Finished
US$25.00
-
Penelope Architect Creme Brulee Finished 1oz
US$15.00
-
Rabbit Hole Heigold Single Barrel Cask Strength
US$35.00
-
Rabbit Hole Heigold Single Barrel Cask Strength 1oz
US$19.00
-
Four Roses OESO
US$18.00
-
Penelope Estate Collection Private Selection
US$27.00
-
Penelope Estate Collection Private Selection 1oz
US$16.00
-
Basil Hayden Malted Rye 1oz
US$13.00
-
Angel's Envy Single Barrel OHLQ
US$35.00
-
Angel's Envy OHLQ Single Barrel 1oz
US$20.00
-
Watershed Uncut Unfiltered Bourbon
US$25.00
-
Watershed Uncut Unfiltered Bourbon 1oz
US$15.00
-
Old Forester "The President's Choice" Single Barrel Bourbon
US$86.00
-
Old Forester "The President's Choice" Single Barrel Bourbon 1oz
US$50.00
-
Old Forester "The President's Choice" Single Barrel Rye
US$86.00
-
Old Forester "The President's Choice" Single Barrel Rye 1oz
US$50.00
-
Watershed Fall Finishing Nocino Barrels
US$35.00
-
Watershed Fall Finishing Nocino Barrels 1oz
US$20.00
-
Watershed Fall Finishing Toasted Oak Barrels
US$32.00
-
Watershed Fall Finishing Toasted Oak Barrels 1oz
US$19.00
-
Wattie Boone & Sons
US$32.00
-
Wattie Boone & Sons 1oz
US$19.00
-
Preservation Estate
US$44.00
-
Preservation Estate 1oz
US$25.00
Draft
-
Abita Amber Ale
US$5.57
-
Sierra Nevada Pale Ale
US$7.42
-
Northern Row Barrister Kolsch
US$4.64
-
Westside G.I.L.
US$5.57
-
Westside Bock
US$8.00
-
Esoteric Irish Red
US$5.57
-
Country Boy Prohibition Lager
US$6.00
-
Urban Artifact "Capy Snacks" Black Raspberry Ale
US$5.57
-
Founder's Mortal Bloom
US$6.49
-
Rhinegeist Mango Bubbles
US$7.42
-
Abita Purple Haze
US$5.57
-
Madtree Legendary Lager
US$5.57
-
Rhinegeist Bubbles
US$7.42
-
Allagash White Belgium Wheat
US$7.42
-
Samuel Adams Oktoberfest
US$6.49
-
Westside Oktoberfest
US$7.42
-
Alesmith Speedway Stout
US$8.35
-
Branch & Bone Gorlami Italian Pilsner
US$7.42
-
Ciderboys Caramel Apple
US$7.42
-
Weihenstephaner Festbier
US$8.35
-
Coors Light
US$4.64
LTO Cocktails
-
El Diablo Caliente
US$8.00
-
Woodinville Rye Paper Plane
US$13.00
-
Midnight Mocha
US$10.00
-
Key to the Heart
US$12.00
-
Love Fever
US$14.00
-
Art of Seduction
US$12.00
-
Cupid's Arrow
US$5.00
-
Whistlepig Boulevardier
US$15.00
-
Irish Surprise
US$12.00
-
Remus Mule
US$6.00
-
Spa-Tron Vibes
US$12.00
-
Oaxaca's Revenge
US$12.00
-
Vamos a la Playa
US$12.00
-
Kickin' Julep
US$12.00
-
Horse's Neck
US$12.00
-
Pinhook Boilermaker
US$15.00
-
Patron Cristalino Mule Special
US$12.00
-
Underberg Special
US$5.00
-
The Rio Grande
US$13.00
-
The Freddie
US$12.00
-
A Family Affair
US$10.00
Seasonal
-
Top of the Morning
US$8.00
-
That Ain't No Snozzberry!
US$8.00
-
Pinga Padua
US$8.00
-
Fit for a Queen
US$8.00
-
Blushing Gardens
US$8.00
-
Velvet Bloom
US$8.00
-
5pm in Jalisco
US$11.00
-
Patio Pleaser
US$8.00
-
Loca for the Coca
US$8.00
-
Split Decision
US$8.00
-
Coconut Kiss
US$8.00
-
Something like Home
US$13.00
-
S'more of What?
US$13.00
-
What's Quackin'
US$13.00
-
Pimenta Del Sol
US$13.00
-
The Caucasian
US$13.00
-
Save the Bees!
US$13.00
Sushi Shop Lausanne Menu
El Faro Club de Mar Menu
NORDSEE T&R Lonetal West Menu
Pho Mama Menu
